Menstrual Dysfunction in Adolescents with Chronic Illness: A Systematic Review

Abstract

Study objective: Menstrual dysfunction can impact both the physical and emotional health of young people.¹ Multiple chronic diseases have been associated with menstrual dysfunction in adults²; however, there is little research in adolescents, despite nonadherence and suboptimal illness control in this group. We aimed to identify the impact of chronic illness on the age of menarche and the menstrual cycle in adolescents.

Methods: Studies were extracted of female adolescents aged 10-19 who had a chronic physical illness. Data included outcomes on age of menarche and/or menstrual cycle quality. Exclusion criteria aimed to exclude diseases where menstrual dysfunction was a known part of the disease pathophysiology (ie, polycystic ovarian syndrome)³ or in which medications were used that directly impacted gonadal function.⁴ A literature search (to January 2022) was performed on the EMBASE, PubMed, and Cochrane library databases. Two widely used modified quality analysis tools were used.

Results: Our initial search netted 1451 articles, of which 95 full texts were examined and 43 met the inclusion criteria. Twenty-seven papers focused on type 1 diabetes (T1D), with 8 papers examining adolescents with cystic fibrosis and the remaining studying inflammatory bowel disease, juvenile idiopathic arthritis, coeliac disease, and chronic renal disease. Metanalysis of 933 patients with T1D vs 5244 controls demonstrated a significantly later age of menarche in T1D (by 0.42 years; P ≤ .00001). There was also a significant association between higher HbA1c and insulin dose (IU/kg) and later age of menarche. Eighteen papers reviewed other aspects of menstruation, including dysmenorrhea, oligomenorrhoea, amenorrhea, and ovulatory function, with variable findings.

Conclusion: Most studies were small and in single populations. Despite this, there was evidence of delayed menarche and some evidence of irregular menses in those with cystic fibrosis and T1D. Further structured studies are needed to evaluate menstrual dysfunction in adolescents and how it relates to their chronic illness.

Keywords: Adolescent; Chronic disease; Diabetes mellitus; Menarche; Menstrual cycle; Type 1.