Post-transplant lymphoproliferative disorders (PTLD) are typically Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-associated lymphoid or plasmacytic proliferations that occur when immunosuppressed after transplantation. Only 2 cases of primary central nervous system (PCNS) classic Hodgkin lymphoma PTLD and 1 case of PCNS Hodgkin lymphoma-like PTLD have been previously reported. A 59-year-old male presented with malaise, headaches, and dizziness; neuroimaging revealed a 1.7-cm right cerebellar mass and a 0.6-cm right frontal mass. Microscopic examination demonstrated a perivascular and parenchymal polymorphous infiltrate composed of lymphocytes (CD3-positive T cells and CD20-positive B cells), plasma cells, and macrophages. Focally, macrophages had a spindled morphology with a fascicular arrangement amounting to poorly formed granulomata. Mitoses were seen. Scattered large atypical cells were visualized with irregular hyperchromatic nuclei, reminiscent of lacunar cells, mononuclear Hodgkin and binucleate Reed-Sternberg (RS) cells. EBV in situ highlighted a significant number of small lymphoid cells as well as many large atypical forms. Large atypical cells were seen to co-express CD15 and CD30. To our knowledge, this is the first such case with hybrid polymorphic PTLD and classic Hodgkin lymphoma features and the first such case to arise following liver transplantation. This case highlights the histological and immunophenotypic spectrum of these lymphoid proliferations and the resulting challenges in diagnosis and definitive subtyping.