HAT1 is a central regulator of chromatin synthesis that acetylates nascent histone H4. To ascertain whether targeting HAT1 is a viable anticancer treatment strategy, we sought to identify small-molecule inhibitors of HAT1 by developing a high-throughput HAT1 acetyl-click assay. Screening of small-molecule libraries led to the discovery of multiple riboflavin analogs that inhibited HAT1 enzymatic activity. Compounds were refined by synthesis and testing of over 70 analogs, which yielded structure-activity relationships. The isoalloxazine core was required for enzymatic inhibition, whereas modifications of the ribityl side chain improved enzymatic potency and cellular growth suppression. One compound (JG-2016 [24a]) showed relative specificity toward HAT1 compared to other acetyltransferases, suppressed the growth of human cancer cell lines, impaired enzymatic activity in cellulo, and interfered with tumor growth. This is the first report of a small-molecule inhibitor of the HAT1 enzyme complex and represents a step toward targeting this pathway for cancer therapy.