Characterization of noise in long-term ECG monitoring with machine learning based on clinical criteria

Abstract

Noise and artifacts affect strongly the quality of the electrocardiogram (ECG) in long-term ECG monitoring (LTM), making some of its parts impractical for diagnosis. The clinical severity of noise defines a qualitative quality score according to the manner clinicians make the interpretation of the ECG, in contrast to assess noise from a quantitative standpoint. So clinical noise refers to a scale of different levels of qualitative severity of noise which aims at elucidating which ECG fragments are valid to achieve diagnosis from a clinical point of view, unlike the traditional approach, which assesses noise in terms of quantitative severity. This work proposes the use of machine learning (ML) techniques to categorize different qualitative noise severity using a database annotated according to a clinical noise taxonomy as gold standard. A comparative study is carried out using five representative ML methods, namely, K neareast neighbors, decision trees, support vector machine, single-layer perceptron, and random forest. The models are fed by signal quality indexes characterizing the waveform in time and frequency domains, as well as from a statistical viewpoint, to distinguish between clinically valid ECG segments from invalid ones. A solid methodology to prevent overfitting to both the dataset and the patient is developed, taking into account balance of classes, patient separation, and patient rotation in the test set. All the proposed learning systems have demonstrated good classification performance, attaining a recall, precision, and F1 score up to 0.78, 0.80, and 0.77, respectively, in the test set by a single-layer perceptron approach. These systems provide a classification solution for assessing the clinical quality of the ECG taken from LTM recordings. Graphical Abstract Clinical Noise Severity Classification based on Machine Learning techniques towards Long-Term ECG Monitoring.

Keywords: Clinical noise severity; Electrocardiogram (ECG); Long-term monitoring (LTM); Machine learning (ML); Signal quality.