To prospectively determine whether brain tumors will respond to immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs), we developed a novel mRNA vaccine as a viral mimic to elucidate cytokine release from brain cancer cells in vitro. Our results indicate that cytokine signatures following mRNA challenge differ substantially from ICI responsive versus non-responsive murine tumors. These findings allow for creation of a diagnostic assay to quickly assess brain tumor immunogenicity, allowing for informed treatment with ICI or lack thereof in poorly immunogenic settings.