Optimal drilling at femoral head-neck junction for treatment of the femoral head necrosis: Experimental and numerical evaluation

Abstract

Background: Advanced core decompression (ACD) is a relative new technique for treatment of early stages of avascular femoral head necrosis. Although it is a promising treatment option, there is a need to modify this technique for achieving higher hip survival rates. An idea was to combine this technique with the lightbulb procedure in order to get a complete removal of the necrosis. This study aimed at evaluating the fracture risk of the femora treated by the combined Lightbulb-ACD technique as the basis for clinical application.

Methods: Subject-specific models were generated from CT scan data of five intact femora. Several treated models were then created from each intact bone and simulated during normal walking activity. Biomechanical testing was additionally performed on 12 pairs of cadaver femora to confirm the simulation results.

Findings: The finite element results revealed that the risk factor of the treated models with a 8 mm-drill increased, but was not significantly greater than that of their corresponding intact models. However, for the femur treated with a 10 mm-drill, the risk factor increased significantly. Fracture always initiated on the femoral neck, i.e. it was either subcapital or transcervical fracture. Our biomechanical testing results correlated well with the simulation data which confirmed the usefulness and effectiveness of the bone models.

Interpretation: The combined Lightbulb-ACD technique using a 10 mm drill increased the fracture risk of femur postoperatively. A drill of up to 8 mm at the anterior head-neck junction did not however lead to the weakening of the femur so that full load bearing may be possible.

Keywords: Biomechanical testing; Bone substitute; Core decompression; Femoral head necrosis; Finite element simulation; Fracture risk; Lightbulb procedure.