Disparities among Japanese municipalities in recommendations for routine and catch-up HPV vaccinations

Abstract

In November 2021, the government of Japan announced a reversal of its decision in 2013 to suspend the previous proactive recommendation for HPV vaccination. However, the program for young girls to receive routine and catch-up vaccinations has not necessarily developed as expected. We conducted a nationwide questionnaire survey by mail in September 2022. The survey was mailed to 133 municipalities consisting of all cities/wards of the Tokyo and Osaka Prefectures and all other prefectural capital cities. Responses were received from 82 municipalities (62.7%). Notification of routine HPV vaccinations had already been sent to 76 (92.7%) of the municipalities; 70 (85.4%) had been encouraged to promote catch-up vaccinations. The questionnaire forms for registration and pre-vaccination screening for routine immunization had been sent to 74.1% (60/81) of the municipalities and 68.8% (55/80) for catch-up immunizations. For catch-up vaccination, only 54 municipalities (65.9%) had detailed vaccination records for those eligible. In total, 10 municipalities (12.2%) had virtually no vaccination records because these had already been discarded. In addition, 61 municipalities (74.4%) had notified only women and girls eligible for a catch-up vaccination based on their vaccination record, whereas 25.6% (21/82) of the municipalities reported that they had sent, or would send, the notification to all women and girls within the targeted grades, including those who had already been vaccinated with three injections. The survey revealed disparities among the municipalities in their HPV vaccine notification processes. Future research on monitoring HPV vaccination rates and incidence rates of cervical cancer and precancerous lesions in each municipality will be desirable.

Keywords: HPV vaccine; disparity; municipality; recommendation; vaccination record.