Measuring the immeasurable: A structural equation modeling approach to assessing soil health

Abstract

Soil health is recognized as an important ecosystem property sensitive to human impact. As a concept, soil health cannot be directly measured, and so assessment and modeling efforts largely rely upon key biological, chemical, and physical indicators. Efforts to develop an overall soil health index are largely lacking due to significant statistical challenges and the necessity for regional calibration. Taken from the field of educational research, structural equation modeling (SEM) is an attractive approach to enhance the reliability and validity of soil health scoring. Therefore, SEM may be utilized to advance research efforts to understand management practices impacts on soil health. Our objectives were to develop a robust scoring function that (i) captures the concept of soil health and latent variables, (ii) adjusts scores by inherent soil properties and legacy of intensive land use to adequately reflect our regional conditions and contemporary land management, and (iii) meets the diverse practitioner needs. Through this process, we refined our minimum dataset of soil health indicators and reconceptualized soil health indicators into functional properties. Our results support the development of a robust single level or a multilevel SEM model-depending on the practitioner's goals-that accounts for repeated sampling or pseudoreplication. While the SEM scoring functions were highly related to the conventional scoring approach, SEM outperformed the conventional methods in terms of its wider distribution of scores-and thus enhanced discriminatory power on the lower and higher range of scores. We also confirmed that the SEM scoring function that includes adjustments for mineralogy and legacy of intensive land use successfully differentiates among contemporary management practices and land use. Therefore, we have confidence that the tool is reliable and appropriate to further examine more nuanced impacts of land use change and management practices within a given land use across time and space covering a diversity of soils. (300 words).

Keywords: Land management; Legacy land use; Soil health assessment; Soil mineralogy; Structural equation modeling.