We describe a total synthesis of the rare isocyanoterpene natural product isoneoamphilectane and two of its unnatural diastereomers. The significantly strained ring system of the reported natural product─along with a hypothesis about a biosynthetic relationship to related family members─inspired us to consider a potential misassignment in the structure's relative configuration. As a result, we initially targeted two less strained, more accessible, stereoisomers of the reported natural product. When these compounds failed to exhibit spectroscopic data that matched those of isoneoamphilectane, we embarked on a synthesis of the originally proposed strained structure via an approach that hinged on a challenging cis-to-trans decalone epimerization. Ultimately, we implemented a novel cyclic sulfite pinacol-type rearrangement to generate the strained ring system. Additional features of this work include the application of a stereocontrolled Mukaiyama-Michael addition of an acyclic silylketene acetal, an unusual intramolecular alkoxide-mediated regioselective elimination, and an HAT-mediated alkene hydroazidation to forge the C-N bond of the tertiary isonitrile. Throughout this work, our synthetic planning was heavily guided by computational analyses to inform on key issues of stereochemical control.