Natural History of Chiari 1 Deformity

Abstract

Purpose: Chiari type 1 deformity (Ch1) is associated with bony deformity of the skull base and herniation of cerebellar tonsils more than 5 mm below the foramen magnum. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is used for diagnosis and surgery is advised for symptomatic children. We present a case series using MRI including cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) flow, in children with Ch1 to demonstrate a variety of outcomes, both surgical and spontaneous: spontaneous resolution, spontaneous worsening, postsurgical improvement, and postsurgical deterioration.

Case: A 2-week-old female newborn underwent brain MRI demonstrating an ectopic neurohypophysis, under opercularization suggesting brain immaturity and a normal craniocervical junction (CCJ). Follow-up (F/U) MRI at 6 years of age showed interval spontaneous development of Ch1 with decreased CSF spaces at CCJ.

Case: A 6-year-old girl referred for imaging with short stature and growth hormone deficiency demonstrated incidental findings of Ch1 without syringomyelia. There was 15-mm protrusion of pointed cerebellar tonsils through the foramen magnum and a reduced CSF space at the craniocervical junction. No surgery was performed, and F/U MRI at the age of 7 years demonstrated spontaneous resolution of the tonsillar ectopia (cerebellar tonsils now 3 mm right and 6 mm left) and expansion of the CSF spaces at CCJ.

Case: A 7-year-old boy with headaches and staring spells underwent an MRI demonstrating 6-mm protrusion of pointed cerebellar tonsils and CSF space reduction at CCJ. No surgery was performed, and F/U imaging at the age of 9 years demonstrated spontaneous improvement in cerebellar tonsillar position and increased bidirectional CSF flow at CCJ.

Case: A 17-month-old boy underwent brain MRI for unsteady gait and poor vestibular response, which showed Ch1 and narrow CSF spaces at the foramen magnum and with reduced CSF flow. At the age of 3 years, after posterior fossa decompression, F/U MRI showed postsurgical improvement of the position of the cerebellar tonsils and increased CSF space at CCJ.

Case: A 4-month-old male infant with a history of 34-week prematurity, prior germinal matrix hemorrhage, and neonatal subdural hemorrhage was referred for MRI of the cervical and thoracic spine for evaluation of developmental delay and hypotonia with torticollis. Magnetic resonance imaging of the spine demonstrated mild protrusion of inferiorly pointed cerebellar tonsils up to the foramen magnum, with visible CSF and without retroflexion of the dens. Follow-up MRI scans demonstrated progressive worsening of the Chiari 1 deformity, even after multiple surgeries.

Conclusions: It is important to be aware of a variety of different outcomes with Ch1, including spontaneous resolution, spontaneous worsening, improvement with surgery, and even deterioration after surgery. More research is required to determine objective criteria for predicting outcome, which include both anatomic measures and physiologic measures of CSF flow, so that better surgical decisions can be made and for evaluating patients who have undergone surgery.