The significant structural diversity and potent bioactivity of the fungal indole diterpenes (IDTs) has attracted considerable interest in their biosynthesis. Although substantial skeletal diversity is generated by the action of noncanonical terpene cyclases, comparatively little is known about these enzymes, particularly those involved in the generation of the subgroup containing emindole SA and DA, which show alternate terpenoid skeletons. Here, we describe the IDT biosynthetic machinery generating these unusual IDT architectures from Aspergillus striatus and Aspergillus desertorum. The function of four putative cyclases was interrogated via heterologous expression. Two specific cyclases were identified that catalyze the formation of epimers emindole SA and DA from A. striatus and A. desertorum, respectively. These cyclases are both clustered along with all the elements required for basic IDT biosynthesis yet catalyze an unusual Markovnikov-like cyclization cascade with alternate stereochemical control. Their identification reveals that these alternate architectures are not generated by mechanistically sloppy or promiscuous enzymes, but by cyclases capable of delivering precise regio- and stereospecificities.