Contribution of collagen degradation and proteoglycan depletion to cartilage degeneration in primary and secondary osteoarthritis: an in silico study

Abstract

Objectives: Current experimental approaches cannot elucidate the effect of maladaptive changes on the main cartilage constituents during the degeneration process in osteoarthritis (OA). In silico approaches, however, allow creating 'virtual knock-out' cases to elucidate these effects in a constituent-specific manner. We used such an approach to study the main mechanisms of cartilage degeneration in different mechanical loadings associated with the following OA etiologies: (1) physiological loading of degenerated cartilage, (2) injurious loading of healthy intact cartilage and (3) physiological loading of cartilage with a focal defect.

Methods: We used the recently developed Cartilage Adaptive REorientation Degeneration (CARED) framework to simulate cartilage degeneration associated with primary and secondary OA (OA cases (1)-(3)). CARED incorporates numerical description of tissue-level cartilage degeneration mechanisms in OA, namely, collagen degradation, collagen reorientation, fixed charged density loss and tissue hydration increase following mechanical loading. We created 'virtual knock-out' scenarios by deactivating these degenerative processes one at a time in each of the three OA cases.

Results: In the injurious loading of intact and physiological loading of degenerated cartilage, collagen degradation drives degenerative changes through fixed charge density loss and tissue hydration rise. In contrast, the two later mechanisms were more prominent in the focal defect cartilage model.

Conclusion: The virtual knock-out models reveal that injurious loading to intact cartilage and physiological loading to degenerated cartilage induce initial degenerative changes in the collagen network, whereas, in the presence of a focal cartilage defect, mechanical loading initially causes proteoglycans (PG) depletion, before changes in the collagen fibril network occur.

Keywords: Adaptive modeling; Articular cartilage; Finite element analysis; In silico techniques; Mechanobiology; Osteoarthritis.