Ecotoxicological effects of fluvial eroded bitumen sediments from the Alberta oil sands to model aquatic species

Abstract

To fully understand the ecological and cumulative effects of mining activities on the surrounding aquatic systems of the Canadian oil sands region, it is essential to understand the consequences of exposure to bitumen-containing soils/sediment from natural geomorphological processes. Both physical and chemical stress on aquatic biota can potentially result from exposure to natural bitumen, resulting from hillslope erosional processes and slumping of bankside soils into the rivers, affecting both riverbed habitat and water quality. The magnitude and duration of bitumen-containing soil's fluvial soils/erosional input into receiving watersheds depends on the interannual variability in the regional hydroclimatology and related seasonal and extreme flow events. The primary objective of this study was to evaluate the potential ecotoxicological effects associated with erosional input of riverbank bitumen soils using controlled exposures. A series of integrated, laboratory-based ecotoxicological bioassays were conducted using organisms with different ecological and functional traits (Daphnia magna (Cladocera), Physa acuta (Gastropoda), and Aliivibrio fischeri (Bacteria)). All model organisms were exposed to elutriates produced from natural bitumen from four different regional rivers: fresh bitumen from shoreline outcrops at the Steepbank River upper and lower reaches (STB-CF and STB-MF, respectively) and the lower-Ells River (EL-MF) and aged, fluvially processed/weathered bitumen from the shoreline of the Athabasca River (ATB-MF). All tested organisms responded negatively to STB-MF and EL-MF elutriates. Low toxicity was also observed in the STB-CF and ATB-MF samples. These results follow the chemical analysis of the parental material and elutriates, where higher levels of metals, polycyclic aromatic compounds and naphthenic acids were detected in the EL-MF sample. In summary, this study shows that eroded and transported bitumen-containing soils and sediments could be a natural source of contaminant exposure to aquatic biota. This fluvial pathway should be considered when assessing background toxicity and the toxicological and ecological effects of oil sands mining activities.

Keywords: Bitumen elutriate toxicity; Fluvial erosion; Natural contamination; Weathered bitumen.