Effect of reciprocal headgear forces on the calvarium: A finite element study

Abstract

Introduction: Orthopedic appliances continue to be used for various sagittal, vertical, and transverse corrections of the maxilla. Although cranial growth can continue to adulthood, no study has drawn attention to the effects of headgear forces on the calvarium, in which anchorage is taken. This study focused on the different biomechanical responses on the calvarium of young children wearing a high-pull headgear of varying forces, using a 3-dimensional finite element analysis and the possible implications of such changes on the human skull.

Methods: A 3-dimensional finite element model of a 9-year-old child was designed from the computed tomography scan. The material properties of the juvenile skull were assigned. Varying orthopedic forces (400, 500, and 600 g of force) were applied, and the magnitude of displacement and stresses generated on the cranial bones and sutures were interpreted using ANSYS software (version 12.1; Canonsburg, Pa).

Results: Maximum displacement was found for the parietal bone in the inferior direction; parietal and temporal bones in the transverse direction; and frontal, parietal, and temporal bones in the sagittal direction. The least displacement was noted for the occipital bone in all the 3-dimensions. The maximum stresses were concentrated over the region of the lateral margins of the piriform aperture and the medial walls of the orbit. Higher stress values were also found on the parietal bone adjacent to the sagittal suture. The highest value of stresses among the sutures of the craniofacial complex was found to be in the region of the frontonasal, frontomaxillary, and nasomaxillary sutures.

Conclusions: The effects of displacement and stresses obtained from this study suggest a restriction to the growth of the cranial vault and its normal mobility, in turn altering the intracranial tension and causing altered cranial morphology in young, growing children undergoing high-pull headgear therapy. The human cranial system is dynamic throughout life and may be restricted or altered by hereditary or environmental factors.