From Public Eugenics to Private Eugenics: What Does the Future Hold?

JBRA Assist Reprod. 2022 Nov 9;26(4):666-674. doi: 10.5935/1518-0557.20220032.

Abstract

Traditional public eugenics, which was ordered by the State, has been replaced by a kind of private eugenics conducted by parents using reproductive techniques, genetic testing and, eventually in the future, genetic engineering. While traditional eugenics strived to improve the species, the new model aims to satisfy parents' reproductive aspirations. The association between public and private eugenics is an ongoing issue, mostly due to its relation to nazi eugenics. This paper will state that both are eugenics; however, with different characteristics, and thus worthy of different legal and ethical assessments. The paper will contextualize private eugenics in the framework of reproductive rights (legal and ethical perspective) and in the development of genetics and reproductive techniques (scientific perspective). Finally, it will analyze some of the legal consequences of a broader acceptance of private eugenics, namely in terms of liability and tort law. Throughout the paper, the different legal solutions in place in Europe will contextualize its considerations.

Keywords: gene editing; offspring selection; private eugenics; public eugenics; reproductive rights; reproductive techniques.

MeSH terms

  • Eugenics*
  • Genetic Testing*
  • Humans
  • Reproduction