Contrary to prevailing thought, the salt content of supernatants is found to dictate reactivity differences of different preparation methods of Rieke zinc toward oxidative addition of organohalides. This conclusion is established through combined single-particle microscopy and ensemble spectroscopy experiments, coupled with careful removal or keeping of the supernatants during Rieke zinc preparations. Fluorescence microscopy experiments with single-Rieke-zinc-particle resolution determined the microscale surface reactivity of the Rieke zinc in the absence of supernatants, thus pinpointing its inherent reactivity independent of the convoluting supernatant composition. In parallel experiments, scanning electron microscopy, energy-dispersive spectroscopy, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, and inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry characterized the zinc metal chemical composition at the bulk and single-particle levels. Proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy kinetics characterized bench-scale Rieke zinc reactivity in the presence and absence of different supernatants and exogenous salt additives. Together, these experiments show that the differences in reactivity from sodium-reduced vs lithium-reduced Rieke zinc arise from the residual salts in the supernatant rather than the differing salt compositions of the solids. This supernatant salt also determines the structure of the ultimate organozinc product, generating either the diorganozinc or monoorganozinc halide complex. That different organozinc complexes formed upon direct insertion to different preparations of Rieke zinc was not previously reported, despite Rieke zinc's widespread use. These findings impact organozinc-reagent and nanomaterial synthesis by showing that, unexpectedly, desired Rieke zinc reactivity can be achieved through simple addition of soluble salts to solutions that were used to prepare the metals─a substantially easier synthetic manipulation than solid composition and morphology control.