An index-based approach for a comprehensive evaluation of the potential risk for active substances and their mixtures to impact the environment was developed. Some of the indices considered already exist (PRISW-1, Priority Index), while others were created ex novo from indicators available on open-source platforms (PESTi, ECOi, AGROi). These indices maybe used for an evaluation before use of pesticides by farmers and advisers. The present approach was initially validated for herbicides in maize crops, but it can readily be applied to other PPPs and crops. PESTi index underline the physical and chemical characteristics as a whole, not considering the impact of other factors such as application rate or period of application. Hence, this index may underestimate the risk associated to a certain chemical. AGROi has a precautionary approach. The risk associated to a specific mixture derives from a combination of intrinsic characteristics of the chemicals, agronomic impacts, regulation restrictions and potential hazard to water compartment. The ECOi index is focused on the ecotoxicological impact against non-target organisms. The helpfulness of this index stands in its ability to easily discriminate the ecotoxicological impact of chemicals using indicators commonly available in literature and without making complex calculations. PRISW-1 Index discriminate active substances according to their risk against three representative non-target organisms. However, due to the intrinsic characteristics of each pesticide, a high PRISW-1 value could not always mean an easy movement of the chemical via runoff waters. The information deriving from Priority index may certainly help public authorities to select chemicals to be detected in water monitoring campaigns. The application of these indices may represent a valid decision tool for public stakeholders in defining agricultural measures to reduce the externalities of pest control.
Keywords: Indices; Pesticides; Risk assessment.
Copyright © 2022 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.