Mesial-Temporal Epileptic Ripples Correlate With Verbal Memory Impairment

Abstract

Rationale: High frequency oscillations (HFO; ripples = 80-200, fast ripples 200-500 Hz) are promising epileptic biomarkers in patients with epilepsy. However, especially in temporal epilepsies differentiation of epileptic and physiological HFO activity still remains a challenge. Physiological sleep-spindle-ripple formations are known to play a role in slow-wave-sleep memory consolidation. This study aimed to find out if higher rates of mesial-temporal spindle-ripples correlate with good memory performance in epilepsy patients and if surgical removal of spindle-ripple-generating brain tissue correlates with a decline in memory performance. In contrast, we hypothesized that higher rates of overall ripples or ripples associated with interictal epileptic spikes correlate with poor memory performance.

Methods: Patients with epilepsy implanted with electrodes in mesial-temporal structures, neuropsychological memory testing and subsequent epilepsy surgery were included. Ripples and epileptic spikes were automatically detected in intracranial EEG and sleep-spindles in scalp EEG. The coupling of ripples to spindles was automatically analyzed. Mesial-temporal spindle-ripple rates in the speech-dominant-hemisphere (left in all patients) were correlated with verbal memory test results, whereas ripple rates in the non-speech-dominant hemisphere were correlated with non-verbal memory test performance, using Spearman correlation).

Results: Intracranial EEG and memory test results from 25 patients could be included. All ripple rates were significantly higher in seizure onset zone channels (p < 0.001). Patients with pre-surgical verbal memory impairment had significantly higher overall ripple rates in left mesial-temporal channels than patients with intact verbal memory (Mann-Whitney-U-Test: p = 0.039). Spearman correlations showed highly significant negative correlations of the pre-surgical verbal memory performance with left mesial-temporal spike associated ripples (r_s = -0.458; p = 0.007) and overall ripples (r_s = -0.475; p = 0.006). All three ripple types in right-sided mesial-temporal channels did not correlate with pre-surgical nonverbal memory. No correlation for the difference between post- and pre-surgical memory and pre-surgical spindle-ripple rates was seen in patients with left-sided temporal or mesial-temporal surgery.

Discussion: This study fails to establish a clear link between memory performance and spindle ripples. This highly suggests that spindle-ripples are only a small portion of physiological ripples contributing to memory performance. More importantly, this study indicates that spindle-ripples do not necessarily compromise the predictive value of ripples in patients with temporal epilepsy. The majority of ripples were clearly linked to areas with poor memory function.

Keywords: epilepsy; high frequency oscillations (HFO); memory; ripples; sleep spindles; temporal lobe epilepsy.