A Comparison of Particulate Exposure Levels during Taxi, Bus, and Metro Commuting among Four Chinese Megacities

Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2022 May 10;19(10):5830. doi: 10.3390/ijerph19105830.

Abstract

Exposure to inhalable particulate matter pollution is a hazard to human health. Many studies have examined the in-transit particulate matter pollution across multiple travel modes. However, limited information is available on the comparison of in-transit exposure among cities that experience different climates and weather patterns. This study aimed to examine the variations in in-cabin particle concentrations during taxi, bus, and metro commutes among four megacities located in the inland and coastal areas of China. To this end, we employed a portable monitoring approach to measure in-transit particle concentrations and the corresponding transit conditions using spatiotemporal information. The results highlighted significant differences in in-cabin particle concentrations among the four cities, indicating that PM concentrations varied in an ascending order of, and the ratios of different-sized particle concentrations varied in a descending order of CS, SZ, GZ, and WH. Variations in in-cabin particle concentrations during bus and metro transits between cities were mainly positively associated with urban background particle concentrations. Unlike those in bus and metro transit, in-cabin PM concentrations in taxi transit were negatively associated with urban precipitation and wind speed. The variations in particle concentrations during the trip were significantly associated with passenger density, posture, the in-cabin location of investigators, and window condition, some of which showed interactive effects. Our findings suggest that improving the urban background environment is essential for reducing particulate pollution in public transport microenvironments. Moreover, optimizing the scheduling of buses and the distribution of bus stops might contribute to mitigating the in-cabin exposure levels in transit. With reference to our methods and insights, policymakers and other researchers may further explore in-transit exposure to particle pollution in different cities.

Keywords: Chinese megacities; commuting exposure; particulate matter (PM); spatiotemporal information; transport microenvironments (TMEs).

Publication types

  • Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't

MeSH terms

  • Automobiles
  • Cities
  • Dust
  • Humans
  • Motor Vehicles*
  • Particulate Matter / analysis
  • Transportation*

Substances

  • Dust
  • Particulate Matter

Grants and funding

This research was funded by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC) [Number: 41901389], Guangdong Science and Technology Strategic Innovation Fund (the Guangdong–Hong Kong-Macau Joint Laboratory Program), [Number: 2020B1212030009], and Shenzhen Key Laboratory of Digital Twin Technologies for Cities [Number: ZDSYS20210623101800001]. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. The authors are grateful to J.H., Y.W., D.Z., B.W., Z.L. and Z.L. for performing the observations.