The addition of carbonaceous materials into anaerobic digestion (AD) has gained widespread attention due to their significant effects on anaerobic performance and antibiotic resistance gene (ARG) removal. This study selected graphite, graphene, and graphene oxide (GO) as additives to investigate variations in AD performance, ARG removal, microbial community diversity and structure in wet AD systems. The results indicated that the addition of graphite-based materials in wet AD systems could increase degradation of solid organic matters by 0.91%-3.41% and utilization of soluble organic fractions by 10.43%-13.67%, but could not stimulate methane production. After the addition of graphite and graphene, ARG removal rates were effectively increased to 90.85% and 94.22%, respectively. However, the total ARG removal rate was reduced to 77.46% with the addition of GO. In addition, the microbial diversity in the wet AD process was enhanced with the addition of GO only, graphite and graphene led to a reduction in it. As for bacterial community, graphite and graphene increased the abundance of Thermotogae from 43.43% to 57.42% and 58.74%, while GO increased the abundance of Firmicute from 49.90% to 56.27%. For the archaeal community, the proportion of hydrogenotrophic methanogens was improved when adding each graphite-based material; however, only GO increased Methanosaeta that was acetoclastic methanogens. Finally, methanogens were found as the ARG host, and ARGs that belong to the same subtype might exist in the same host bacteria.
Keywords: Wet anaerobic digestion; antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs); graphene; graphene oxide; graphite.