Combining stimuli-responsive properties of gels with adhesive properties of mussels is highly interesting for a large field of applications as, e.g., in life science. Therefore, the present paper focuses on the copolymerization of poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAM) microgels with dopamine methacrylamide (DMA). A detailed understanding of reaction kinetics is crucial to figure out an optimized synthesis strategy for tailoring microgels with adhesive properties. The present study addresses the influence of relevant synthesis parameters as the injection time of DMA during the microgel synthesis and the overall reaction time of the microgel. Reaction kinetics were studied by mass spectrometry of time samples taken during the microgel synthesis. This allowed us to determine the monomer consumption of NIPAM, the cross-linker N,N'-methylenebisacrylamide (BIS), and DMA. A second-order reaction kinetics was found for DMA incorporation. The amount of DMA incorporated in the resulting microgel was successfully determined by a combination of UV-vis and NMR spectroscopy to level off limitations of both methods. The dependence of the hydrodynamic radius on temperature was determined by DLS measurements for the microgels. While an early injection of DMA stops the PNIPAM polymerization due to scavenging, it greatly enhances the reaction speed of DMA. The faster reaction of DMA and the incomplete NIPAM and BIS conversion also compensate for shorter reaction times with respect to the incorporated amount of DMA. On the contrary, a later injection of DMA leads to a full NIPAM monomer and BIS cross-linker consumption. An overall reaction time of 60 min ensures the DMA incorporation. Longer reaction times lead to clumping. First adhesion tests show an increased adhesion of P(NIPAM-co-DMA) microgels compared to pure PNIPAM microgels, when mechanical stress is applied.