Robustness and stability of volume-based tractography in a multicenter setting

Abstract

Muscle diffusion tensor imaging (mDTI)-based tractography is a promising tool with which to detect subclinical changes in muscle injuries and to evaluate pathophysiology in neuromuscular diseases. Classic region of interest (ROI)-based tractography is very time-consuming and requires an examiner with extensive experience. (Semi)automatic approaches such as volume-based tractography (VBT) can diminish this problem but its robustness and stability are unknown. The aim of the current study was to assess the performance of VBT in a multicenter setting and to evaluate semiautomatic segmentation approaches in the analysis of VBT-derived data in terms of the comparability of the outcome measures. Five traveling volunteers underwent 3-T mDTI of seven calf muscles of both legs at six different MR sites. Tract properties and diffusion metrics were calculated using VBT. Within-subject coefficients of variance (wsCVs) and intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) were calculated to assess the multicenter reproducibility of tract properties such as tract density (TD), mean tract length, volume and tract propagation angle, and diffusion metrics such as fractional anisotropy, mean diffusivity, axial diffusivity (λ₁ ) and radial diffusivity in traveling subjects. Furthermore, 50 individual datasets from five different centers (10 datasets per center) were pooled to assess the feasibility of VBT with manual and semiautomatic segmentation. To assess the differences of tract properties and diffusion metrics between segmentation approaches an ANOVA was performed, and ICC and Bland-Altman plots were analyzed. wsCVs and ICCs showed good reproducibility of the tract properties TD and volume, as well as diffusion metrics. ANOVA showed no significant differences between manual and semiautomatic approaches. ICCs were excellent (≥ 0.992) and Bland-Altman analysis did not reveal any systemic bias between the methods. Tract properties and diffusion metrics derived from VBT showed good comparability among centers. Semiautomatic approaches revealed excellent agreement with gold standard of manual segmentation. These findings suggest that pooling data from different centers to construct a reference database for tractography results is feasible using semiautomatic segmentation approaches.

Keywords: multicenter study; muscle diffusion tensor imaging; reproducibility; skeletal muscle; tractography.