Genetic/genomic testing: defining the parameters for ethical, legal and social implications (ELSI)

BMC Med Ethics. 2021 Nov 23;22(1):156. doi: 10.1186/s12910-021-00720-5.

Abstract

Background: Genetic/genomic testing (GGT) are useful tools for improving health and preventing diseases. Still, since GGT deals with sensitive personal information that could significantly impact a patient's life or that of their family, it becomes imperative to consider Ethical, Legal and Social Implications (ELSI). Thus, ELSI studies aim to identify and address concerns raised by genomic research that could affect individuals, their family, and society. However, there are quantitative and qualitative discrepancies in the literature to describe the elements that provide content to the ELSI studies and such problems may result in patient misinformation and harmful choices.

Methods: We analyzed the major international documents published by international organizations to specify the parameters that define ELSI and the recognized criteria for GGT, which may prove useful for researchers, health professionals and policymakers. First, we defined the parameters of the ethical, legal and social fields in GGT to avoid ambiguities when using the acronym ELSI. Then, we selected nine documents from 44 relevant publications by international organizations related to genomic medicine.

Results: We identified 29 ELSI sub-criteria concerning to GGT, which were organized and grouped within 10 minimum criteria: two from the ethical field, four from the legal field and four from the social field. An additional analysis of the number of appearances of these 29 sub-criteria in the analyzed documents allowed us to order them and to determine 7 priority criteria for starting to evaluate and propose national regulations for GGT.

Conclusions: We propose that the ELSI criteria identified herein could serve as a starting point to formulate national regulation on personalized genomic medicine, ensuring consistency with international bioethical requirements.

Keywords: Bioethics; ELSI criteria; Ethical; Genetic testing; Genomic diseases; Genomic medicine; Genomic testing; Healthcare; Legal and social implications; Patient rights; Policy-making.

Publication types

  • Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't

MeSH terms

  • Ethics, Research
  • Genome, Human
  • Genomic Medicine*
  • Genomics*
  • Humans
  • Precision Medicine