Integrating field and satellite monitoring for assessing environmental risk associated with bacteria in recreational waters of a large reservoir

Abstract

In a large South American Reservoir (750 km², limit between Uruguay and Argentina), we characterized the environmental risk posed by cyanobacteria proxies (abundance, toxin concentration, chlorophyll-a) and Escherichia coli abundances, integrating field (six sites, summers 2011-2015) and satellite (750 km², summers 2011-2017) monitoring. We further assessed how well field cyanobacteria quantitative proxies (abundance, toxin concentration, chlorophyll-a and scum formation) used to build a local risk communication system for recreational (bathing) use of waters named "cyano-traffic-light", ongoing since 2011, reflected its outcome. Cyanobacteria abundance in the field ranged from moderate (>20,000 to <100,000 cells mL^-1) to high-risk (>100,000 cells mL^-1), and its abundance was positively related to toxin (microcystin) concentration. Mean microcystin concentrations was within the low (≤2 μg L^-1, 50% sites) or moderate (>2 < 10 μg L^-1, 50% sites) risk categories. On rare occasions, toxin concentration posed a high-risk for human health. E. coli abundance was within the high-risk category (>126 CFU 100 mL^-1) for human health, mostly in the northern part of the reservoir. Cyanobacteria proxies (abundance and toxins) and E. coli abundance were, however, unrelated. The predictive model showed that, out of the four cyanobacteria proxies used to construct the cyano-traffic-light only cyanobacteria abundance (p < 0.05) explained the outcome of the reports, yet with low explanatory power (41%). The satellite monitoring allowed delimiting the extent and magnitude of the environmental risk posed by cyanobacteria at landscape scale (highest risk in the meander parts of the Argentinean side of the reservoir) and producing risk maps that can be used by water management agencies. Based upon our results we propose including E. coli abundances and satellite derived cyanobacteria abundances in the building of the cyano-traffic-light, among other modifications.

Keywords: Coliform bacteria; Harmful blooms; Microcystin; Risk assessment; Satellites; Water quality.