Belactosins and hormaomycins are peptide natural products containing 3-(2-aminocyclopropyl)alanine and 3-(2-nitrocyclopropyl)alanine residues, respectively, with opposite stereoconfigurations of the cyclopropane ring. Herein we demonstrate that the heme oxygenase-like enzymes BelK and HrmI catalyze the N-oxygenation of l-lysine to generate 6-nitronorleucine. The nonheme iron enzymes BelL and HrmJ then cyclize the nitroalkane moiety to the nitrocyclopropane ring with the desired stereochemistry found in the corresponding natural products. We also show that both cyclopropanases remove the 4-proS-H of 6-nitronorleucine during the cyclization, establishing the inversion and retention of the configuration at C4 during the BelL and HrmJ reactions, respectively. This study reveals the unique strategy for stereocontrolled cyclopropane synthesis in nature.