Nickel superoxide dismutase (NiSOD) is an enzyme that protects cells against O2·-. While the structure of its active site is known, the mechanism of the catalytic cycle is still not elucidated. Its active site displays a square planar NiII center with two thiolates, the terminal amine and an amidate. We report here a bioinspired NiII complex built on an ATCUN-like binding motif modulated with one cysteine, which demonstrates catalytic SOD activity in water (kcat = 8.4(2) × 105 M-1 s-1 at pH = 8.1). Its reactivity with O2·- was also studied in acetonitrile allowing trapping two different short-lived species that were characterized by electron paramagnetic resonance or spectroelectrochemistry and a combination of density functional theory (DFT) and time-dependent DFT calculations. Based on these observations, we propose that O2·- interacts first with the complex outer sphere through a H-bond with the peptide scaffold in a [NiIIO2·-] species. This first species could then evolve into a NiIII hydroperoxo inner sphere species through a reaction driven by protonation that is thermodynamically highly favored according to DFT calculations.