Two iron-based materials, Fe-Ca composite (FeCa) and Fe-Mn binary oxide (FMBO), were applied to immobilize As, Pb, and Cd in heavy metal contaminated paddy soils. Seven kinds of paddy soil (tidal soil) contaminated by arsenic, lead and cadmium were collected from Shangyu, Shaoxing (SY), Foshan, Guangdong (FS), Shaoguan, Guangdong (SG), LiuYang, Hunan (LY), Ganzhou, Jiangxi (GZ), Dushan, Guizhou (DS), and Ma'anshan, Anhui (MAS). The effects of iron-based materials on the dynamic changes of As, Pb, and Cd concentration in soil solution, the stabilization efficacy of available As, Pb, and Cd in soil, and the effects of soil types and properties on stabilization efficacy were studied through soil incubation experiment. The results showed that the content of soil dissolved As, Pb, and Cd were lower in iron-based material treatments than in control throughout the incubation. The addition of two iron-based materials significantly reduced the availability of Cd, Pb, and As. Moreover, the stabilization efficiency of FeCa for As was higher than FMBO, but no significant difference was found in the stabilization efficiency of Pb and Cd between two materials. The stabilization efficiency of As, Pb, and Cd in FeCa treatments could be ordered as GZ > SG > DS and MAS; FS>SY, LY, and SG>MAS; SY, GZ, and DS>MAS, respectively. While the stabilization efficiency for As, Pb, and Cd in FMBO could be ordered as SY, LY, and GZ > DS > FS; FS > GZ > SY; DS > LY > MAS, respectively. In addition, the statistical results showed that the stabilization efficiencies of various soils under the treatment of iron-based materials were significantly correlated with sand content (negatively correlated for As), soil pH (positively correlated for Pb), and clay content (negatively correlated for Cd). In conclusion, the two iron-based materials evaluated in this study may be effective stabilization agents for remediating different types of arsenic-, lead-, and cadmium-contaminated soils.
Keywords: Fe-Ca composite (FeCa); Fe-Mn binary oxide (FMBO); contaminated paddy soil; heavy metals; immobilization; iron-based materials.