Diagnostic accuracy of physical examination findings for midfacial and mandibular fractures

Abstract

Objectives: To assess the diagnostic accuracy of physical examination findings used to identify patients at risk for midfacial or mandibular fractures.

Materials and methods: A five-year retrospective cohort was constructed from all emergency department patients with a midfacial or mandibular trauma. The sensitivity, specificity, pre-test probability, positive predictive value, negative predictive value, positive likelihood ratio and negative likelihood ratio data was calculated for 19 and 14 physical examination findings for midfacial and mandibular fractures respectively. Computed Tomography and panoramic radiography were used as index tests.

Results: A total of 1484 patients were identified among whom 40.4% midfacial and 33.4% mandibular fractures were diagnosed. Overall, specificity was found to be higher than sensitivity. Regarding midfacial fractures, high specificity was found for raccoon eyes, malar eminence flattening and all the findings that are related to palpation, the nasal, ocular and intra-oral assessment. Malar eminence flattening, external nasal deformity, nasal septum hematoma, change of globe position and palpable step-off had ad high positive predictive value and positive likelihood ratio. Regarding mandibular fractures high specificity was found for mouth opening restriction, auditory canal bleeding, intra-oral assessment related findings, palpable step-off, inferior alveolar nerve paresthesia, the angular compression test and chin axial pressure test.

Conclusions: The diagnostic accuracy of relevant physical examination findings were identified for the prediction of midfacial and mandibular fractures.

Keywords: Craniocerebral trauma; Emergency service, hospital; Maxillofacial injuries; Signs and Symptoms; Tomography, Spiral Computed.