Historical control data in ecotoxicology: Eight years of tests with the copepod Acartia tonsa

Abstract

The calanoid copepod Acartia tonsa is one of the most frequently used organisms in acute, short-term bioassays to assess effects induced by marine matrices or chemicals on different life stages. Physiological responses in such tests can be highly variable and historical control data (HCD), values recorded from previous studies performed under similar conditions, can be useful to recognise the average responses over time. Here, we analysed egg hatching success and larval (naupliar) immobilisation/mortality of A. tonsa Mediterranean strain, cultured in laboratory conditions since 2008 and used as model organisms in ecotoxicology tests. Our aims were to evaluate the physiological response and sensitivity of A. tonsa over eight years of bioassays, and to compare our HCD with reference values, in order to assess the suitability of such a long-term culture for ecotoxicology studies. Acartia tonsa eggs were exposed for 48 h to the reference toxicant nickel chloride (NiCl₂) and the % of egg hatching success and naupliar viability were compared to controls. A total of 59 acute tests, displayed in Shewhart-like control charts, showed a high mean percentage of egg hatching success (85.60% ± 5.90 SD) recorded for the whole period, and a low mean percentage of naupliar immobilisation/mortality (6.73% ± 6.38 SD) in controls. Effective concentration (EC₅₀) for NiCl₂ registered a stable mean of 0.14 mg Ni/L (± 0.047 SD) over time. Overall, our long-term dataset confirms the suitability of this copepod species for ecotoxicology studies even after years of culturing in laboratory conditions. It is advisable that other laboratories with long-term datasets made their own control charts, to allow data comparison and to improve test protocols. Considering our HCD, we suggest an EC₅₀ of NiCl₂ of 0.14 ± 0.09 mg Ni/L for acute tests with the Mediterranean strain of A. tonsa.

Keywords: Acute test; Egg hatching success; Naupliar immobilisation/mortality; Nickel chloride; Shewhart control chart; Zooplankton.