Sample-size dependence of validation parameters in linear regression models and in QSAR

SAR QSAR Environ Res. 2021 Apr;32(4):247-268. doi: 10.1080/1062936X.2021.1890208. Epub 2021 Mar 22.

Abstract

The dependence of statistical validation parameters was investigated on the size of the sample taken in fit of multivariate linear curves. We observed that R2 and related internal parameters were misleading as they overestimated the goodness-of-fit of models at small sample size. Cross-validation metrics showed correct trends. It was possible to scale the leave-one-out and the leave-many-out results close to identical by correcting the degrees of freedom of the models. y and x-randomized validation parameters were calculated and the methods provided close to identical results. We suggest to use the simplest methods in both cases. The external parameters followed correct trends with respect to the sample size, but their sensitivity differed. We plotted the Roy-Ojha metrics in 2D and we coloured them with respect to other external parameters to provide an easy classification of models. The rank correlations were calculated between the performance parameters. Up to a sample size, goodness-of-fit and robustness were distinguishable, but above a certain sample size, the parameters were redundant. The external-internal pairs were weakly correlated. Our data show that all the three aspects of validation are necessary at small sample sizes, but the internal check of robustness is not informative above a given sample size.

Keywords: Coefficient of determination; cross-validation; goodness-of-fit; predictivity; robustness.

MeSH terms

  • Linear Models*
  • Quantitative Structure-Activity Relationship*
  • Sample Size