A series of five alcohols (3-methyl-2-butanol, 1-cyclopropylethanol, 1-cyclopentylethanol, 1-cyclohexylethanol, and 1-phenylethanol) was used to study the impact of the size of steric hindrance and its aromaticity on self-assembling phenomena in the liquid phase. In this Letter, we have explicitly shown that the phenyl ring exerts a much stronger effect on the self-organization of molecules via the O-H···O scheme than any other type of steric hindrance, leading to a significant decline in the size and concentration of the H-bonded clusters. Given the combination of calorimetric, dielectric, infrared, and diffraction studies, this phenomenon was ascribed to its additional proton-acceptor function for the competitive intermolecular O-H···π interactions. The consequence of this is a different packing of molecules on the short- and medium-range scale.