Determination of 27 metals in HISS-1, MESS-4 and PACS-3 marine sediment certified reference materials by the BCR sequential extraction

Paramee Kumkrong; Patrick H J Mercier; Indu Pihilligawa Gedara; Ovi Mihai; Daniel D Tyo; Jiang Cindy; David M Kingston; Zoltán Mester

doi:10.1016/j.talanta.2020.121543

Determination of 27 metals in HISS-1, MESS-4 and PACS-3 marine sediment certified reference materials by the BCR sequential extraction

Talanta. 2021 Jan 1:221:121543. doi: 10.1016/j.talanta.2020.121543. Epub 2020 Aug 26.

Authors

Paramee Kumkrong¹, Patrick H J Mercier², Indu Pihilligawa Gedara², Ovi Mihai², Daniel D Tyo², Jiang Cindy², David M Kingston², Zoltán Mester²

Affiliations

¹ National Research Council Canada, 1200, Montreal Road, Ottawa, ON, Canada. Electronic address: paramee.kumkrong@nrc-cnrc.gc.ca.
² National Research Council Canada, 1200, Montreal Road, Ottawa, ON, Canada.

PMID: 33076103
DOI: 10.1016/j.talanta.2020.121543

Abstract

The BCR sequential extraction procedure developed by the European Community Bureau of Reference was applied to the three marine sediment certified reference materials (CRMs). These CRMs are designated as HISS-1, MESS-4, and PACS-3 and comprise respectively pristine, moderately-contaminated, and highly-contaminated sediments, respectively. The study aimed to provide values of extractable elements in reference materials of varied geological origin to support method development and quality control efforts. Concentrations of 27 elements extracted in the three sequential extraction steps and in the residue were determined. The extraction steps consisted of: Step 1 - acetic acid extraction (targeting the exchangeable, water- and acid-soluble fraction); Step 2 - hydroxylammonium chloride extraction (targeting the reducible fraction); and Step 3 - hydrogen peroxide extraction (targeting the oxidizable fraction). The results from two independent laboratories using the sequential extraction procedure for the 27 elements were combined using the DerSimonian-Laird method of analysis implemented in the NIST Consensus Builder software. The percent recovery (sum steps vs total metal content) of 27 elements ranged from 68% to 125% in HISS-1, 76%-119% in MESS-4, and 70%-125% in PACS-3, based on the certified values. The combined uncertainty (k = 2) was from 1% to 39% for HISS-1, 3%-45% for MESS-4, and 3%-21% for PACS-3. Comparing the three extraction steps, the uncertainty of Step 3 was the highest for all the three CRMs. The agglomerate sediments in MESS-4 resulted in high uncertainty when compared to HISS-1 and PACS-3. The method validation showed the BCR sequential extraction procedure can apply to other elements including As, Co, Li, Mn, and V.

Keywords: Certified reference material; Fraction; Marine sediments; Recovery; Sequential extraction; Uncertainty.