The design of protein interaction interfaces is a cornerstone of synthetic biology, where they can be used to promote the association of protein subunits into active molecular complexes or into protein nanostructures. In nature, protein interactions can be modulated by post-translational modifications (PTMs) that modify the protein interfaces with the addition and removal of various chemical groups. PTMs thus represent a means to gain control over protein interactions, yet they have seldom been considered in the design of synthetic proteins. Here, we explore the potential of a reversible PTM, serine phosphorylation, to modulate the interactions between peptides. We designed a series of interacting peptide pairs, including heterodimeric coiled coils, that contained one or more protein kinase A (PKA) recognition motifs. Our set of peptide pairs comprised interactions ranging from nanomolar to micromolar affinities. Mass spectrometry analyses showed that all peptides were excellent phosphorylation substrates of PKA, and subsequent phosphate removal could be catalyzed by lambda protein phosphatase. Binding kinetics measurements performed before and after treatment of the peptides with PKA revealed that phosphorylation of the target serines affected both the association and dissociation rates of the interacting peptides. We observed both the strengthening of interactions (up to an 11-fold decrease in Kd) and the weakening of interactions (up to a 180-fold increase in Kd). De novo-designed PTM-modulated interfaces will be useful to control the association of proteins in biological systems using protein-modifying enzymes, expanding the paradigm of self-assembly to encompass controlled assembly of engineerable protein complexes.