Atopy is excessive production of IgE in response to allergens. We evaluated in patients undergoing allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT) the following hypotheses: (1) Atopy is "curable" in atopic patients receiving HCT from a nonatopic donor (D-R+), and (2) Atopy is transferable from atopic donors to nonatopic recipients (D+R-). Atopic patients with atopic donors (D+R+) and non-atopic patients with non-atopic donors (D-R-) served as controls. We measured levels of multiallergen-specific IgE (A-IgE, atopy defined as ≥0.35 kUA/L) in sera from 54 patients and their donors pre HCT and from the patients at ≥2 years post HCT. Only 7/12 (58%) D- R+ patients became nonatopic after HCT. Only 1/11 (9%) D+R- patients became atopic. Eleven of 13 (85%) D-R- patients remained nonatopic. Unexpectedly, 11/18 (61%) D+R+ patients became nonatopic. In conclusion, contrary to our hypothesis and previous reports, the "cure" of atopy may occur in only some D-R+ patients and the transfer of atopy may occur rarely. The "cure" may not be necessarily due to the exchange of atopic for nonatopic immune system, as the "cure" may also occur in D+R+ patients.