Homogeneous populations of mature differentiated primary cell types can display variable responsiveness to extracellular stimuli, although little is known about the underlying mechanisms that govern such heterogeneity at the level of gene expression. In this article, we show that morphologically homogenous human endothelial cells exhibit heterogeneous expression of VCAM1 after TNF-α stimulation. Variability in VCAM1 expression was not due to stochasticity of intracellular signal transduction but rather to preexisting established heterogeneous states of promoter DNA methylation that were generationally conserved through mitosis. Variability in DNA methylation of the VCAM1 promoter resulted in graded RelA/p65 and RNA polymerase II binding that gave rise to a distribution of VCAM1 transcription in the population after TNF-α stimulation. Microarray analysis and single-cell RNA sequencing revealed that a number of cytokine-inducible genes shared this heterogeneous response pattern. These results show that heritable epigenetic heterogeneity is fundamental in inflammatory signaling and highlight VCAM1 as a metastable epiallele.
Copyright © 2020 by The American Association of Immunologists, Inc.