Why do muscles lose torque potential when activated within their agonistic group?

Abstract

Agonistic muscles lose approximately 20% of their individual torque-generating capacity when activated with their agonistic muscles compared with when stimulated in isolation. In this study, we (1) tested if this loss in torque was accompanied by a corresponding loss in force, thereby testing the potential role of changes in moment arms between conditions; (2) removed all inter-muscular connections between the quadriceps muscles, thus determining the potential role of inter-muscular force transmission; and (3) systematically changed the inter-muscular pressure by performing experiments at different activation/force levels, thereby exploring the possible role of inter-muscular pressure in the loss of torque capacity with simultaneous muscle activation. Experiments were performed in a New Zealand white rabbit quadriceps model (N=5). Torque and force were measured during activation of femoral nerve branches that supply the individual quadriceps muscles while activating these branches simultaneously and in isolation. Regardless of joint angle and inter-muscular connections between muscles, the differences in torque values between the simultaneous and the isolated activation of the quadriceps muscles were also observed for the directly measured force values. Mean differences in simultaneous and isolated muscle activation remained similar between the intact and separated conditions: torque difference 21±5% of maximum isometric torque of intact condition (MIC_torque), versus 19±6% MIC_torque, respectively, and force difference 18±3% MIC_force versus 19±7% MIC_force, respectively. The absolute torque loss was independent of the force, and thus presumably the inter-muscular pressures. Based on these results, we conclude that the torque deficit observed during simultaneous compared with isolated muscle activation is not primarily caused by moment arm, inter-muscular pressure or inter-muscular force transmission. The mechanisms underlying loss of force capacity during agonistic muscle contraction remain unknown.

Keywords: Connective tissue; Inter-muscular; Moment arm; Muscle properties; Pressure.