Shared ground: Between environmental history and the history of science

Hist Sci. 2019 Dec;57(4):403-440. doi: 10.1177/0073275319851013. Epub 2019 Nov 1.

Abstract

Recent years have witnessed a significant expansion in the number of studies positioned at the intersection of the history of science and environmental history. Although these studies continue to navigate lingering methodological tensions, collectively they underscore the promise of a disciplinary cross-fertilization that proved largely latent for the first quarter century or more following environmental history's emergence as a discrete discipline. This article situates this recent scholarship in the historiographical landscape from which it has emerged. To that end, it (a) summarizes the fields' early intersections; (b) examines the ways in which disciplinary tensions made the intersection fraught; (c) traces shifts in both fields that made that intersection more conducive to cross-disciplinary work; and (d) sketches the trajectories of some of the prominent threads of the recent scholarship deliberately situated at the nexus of the disciplines.

Keywords: ASEH; HSS; History of science; constructivism; environmental history; environmental science; historiography; lab–field.