Performance of lower limb prostheses is related not only to the mechanical design and the control scheme, but also to the feedback provided to the user. Proprioceptive feedback, which is the sense of position and movement of one's body parts, can improve the utility as well as facilitate the embodiment of the prosthetic device. Recent studies have shown that proprioceptive kinesthetic (movement) sense can be elicited when non-invasively vibrating a muscle tendon proximal to the targeted joint. However, consistency and quality of the elicited sensation depend on several parameters and muscle tendons after lower limb amputation may not always be accessible. In this study, we developed an experimental protocol to quantitatively and qualitatively assess the elicited proprioceptive kinesthetic illusion when non-invasively vibrating a muscle belly. Furthermore, we explored ways to improve consistency and strength of the illusion by integrating another non-invasive feedback method, namely cutaneous information manipulation via skin stretch. Our preliminary results from tests conducted with a person with transtibial (below knee) amputation show that stretching skin while vibrating a muscle belly on the residual limb provided a stronger and more consistent kinesthetic illusion (90%) than only vibrating the muscle (50%). In addition, we found that stretching skin enhances the range (1.5 times) and speed (3.5 times) of the illusory movement triggered by muscle vibration. These findings may enable the development of mechanisms for controlling feedback parameters in closing the control loop for various walking routines, which may improve performance of lower limb prostheses.