Desmoplastic malignant melanoma (DMM) is an amelanotic spindle cell proliferation that can be mistaken for a cutaneous scar. The distinction can be difficult in reexcisions because DMM is negative for conventional melanoma markers such as HMB-45 and Melan-A, and scars may be positive for S-100 protein and SOX-10. We compare a total of 12 DMM cases with 8 reexcision and 35 old non-reexcision cutaneous scars using SOX-10 immunohistochemical stains. Cell quantification was performed on captured images using ImageJ 1.51t. SOX-10 was expressed in DMM (100%, 12/12), and reexcision (75%, 6/8), atrophic (88%, 22/25), hypertrophic (100%, 8/8), and keloid-type (100%, 2/2) scars. The cellular density of SOX-10 positive cells in DMM (822.9±116.9 cells/mm, mean±SEM) was significantly higher than in any scar subgroup (hypertrophic: 188.4±20.40 cells/mm, atrophic: 83.78±11.13 cells/mm, reexcision: 96.72±30.13 cells/mm, P<0.0001). Hypercellular areas in reexcision scars showed dense positivity as hypocellular areas in DMM (upper limit for scars: 258.42 positive cells/mm vs. lower limit for DMM: 292.42 positive cells/mm). SOX-10 positive cells in scars are predominantly monomorphic and small following the overall directionality of the tissue. In contrast, DMM cells exhibited enlarged atypical nuclei with a haphazard distribution, invasion as single cells or in clusters, and tropism for adnexal structures (58%) and neurovascular bundles (67%). In conclusion, cutaneous scars contain SOX-10 positive cells. The evaluation of residual DMM needs careful attention to morphologic characteristics to avoid over-interpretation of SOX-10 immunostains.