Four new compounds (2-5) structurally related to the microtubule-stabilizing agent (-)-zampanolide (1) have been isolated from the Tongan marine sponge Cacospongia mycofijiensis. Three of these new structures, zampanolides B-D (2-4), exhibit nanomolar cytotoxicity toward the HL-60 cell line, are antimitotic, and induce in vitro tubulin polymerization at levels comparable to 1. Zampanolide E (5), saturated at C-8/C-9, was significantly less potent and does not stabilize purified tubulin, even at 10-fold higher concentrations. The structural differences across these compounds reveal a plasticity of the zampanolide pharmacophore. While unsaturation is required at Δ8, the configuration of this alkene and those of Δ4 and Δ4' have little effect on tubulin polymerization. The first natural co-occurrence of 1 and (-)-dactylolide (6) from the same sponge extract is also noted.