Idiopathic male infertility (IMI) affects nearly 10-15% of men in their prime reproductive age. More than 500 target genes were postulated to be associated with this disease condition through various genomic studies. The challenge is to determine the functional role of these genes and proteins that form part of a larger network leading to pathogenesis of the IMI phenotype in humans. In the current study, we have catalogued all of the genes associated with IMI from published studies, as well as looked at reactive oxygen species and antioxidant genes, the two key physiological determinants essential for normal spermatogenesis. Any imbalance in these genes through mutation, single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) or other forms could result in abnormal regulation of genes leading to infertility. SNPs catalogued in the current study, representing a third of the IMI genes, could possibly explain the various hidden factors associated with this condition. The enriched biological functions in SNPs, as well as functional analysis of IMI genes, resulted in the identification of novel gene pairs, from which we proposed new models to describe the underlying pathogenesis of this disease condition. The outcome of this study will give a new set of genes and proteins that could help explain the disease from a global perspective previously not addressed using standard approaches. Genes corresponding to proteins identified from the current study for spermatozoa and seminal plasma showed functional correlation based on their localization, which gave further confirmation of their roles in defective spermatogenesis as seen in IMI.