Iodine (I2) molecules embedded in He nanodroplets are aligned by a 160 ps long laser pulse. The highest degree of alignment, occurring at the peak of the pulse and quantified by ⟨cos2𝜃2D⟩, is measured as a function of the laser intensity. The results are well described by ⟨cos2𝜃2D⟩ calculated for a gas of isolated molecules each with an effective rotational constant of 0.6 times the gas-phase value and at a temperature of 0.4 K. Theoretical analysis using the angulon quasiparticle to describe rotating molecules in superfluid helium rationalizes why the alignment mechanism is similar to that of isolated molecules with an effective rotational constant. A major advantage of molecules in He droplets is that their 0.4 K temperature leads to stronger alignment than what can generally be achieved for gas phase molecules-here demonstrated by a direct comparison of the droplet results to measurements on a ∼1 K supersonic beam of isolated molecules. This point is further illustrated for a more complex system by measurements on 1,4-diiodobenzene and 1,4-dibromobenzene. For all three molecular species studied, the highest values of ⟨cos2𝜃2D⟩ achieved in He droplets exceed 0.96.