Neutel & Thorne (Ecology Letters, 17:651-661, June 2014) provide an approximation for the leading eigenvalue of a food web community matrix involving coefficients of its characteristic polynomial. Though valuably incorporating three-way species interactions, two critical problems emerge when one considers the dimensions of the system, calling the approach's accuracy and precision into question.
Keywords: Complexity; food webs; negative feedback loop; population dynamics; stability.
© 2015 John Wiley & Sons Ltd/CNRS.