The tilted gel phase of lipid bilayers can display in-plane orientational texture due to long-range alignment of the molecular director. We explore systematic variations of texture defects in a series of binary phospholipid membranes. Using polarized two-photon fluorescence microscopy, the texture pattern of single domains is revealed. The appearance of a central vortex-type defect in each domain correlates with a particular range of hydrophobic mismatch values h > 1 nm at the domain border while domains with h < 1 nm correlate with uniformly aligned texture. The central vortex defect is characterized by a defect angle, indicating its bend or splay nature. Using image analysis, we measure the defect angle and find that it has primarily bend character for small mismatch values (h ≈ 1 nm) and primarily splay nature for larger values of h. For domains containing a vortex, the domain shape is decoupled from the texture while for uniformly textured domains there is a preferred texture orientation of ≃45° along the domain border. The results establish a foundation for understanding texture phenomena in compositionally complex membranes.