Science meets regulation

Abstract

Ethnopharmacological relevance: The European Pharmacopoeia (Ph. Eur.) is a standard reference for both European and non-European countries and defines requirements for the qualitative and quantitative composition of medicines. Herbal drug (HD) monographs state which aspects have to be considered for quality assurance through the relevant chapters "Definition", "Characters", "Identification", "Tests", and "Assay". Identification of botanical material is achieved by macroscopic and microscopic morphology, generally examined by a trained expert. Content or assay is the most difficult area of quality control to perform, since in most herbal drugs the active constituents are unknown and markers should be used which cannot be really related to the quality. The other critical points are represented by the purity tests, in particular some tests such as heavy metals, aflatoxins and pesticides are laborious and time intensive, requiring a significant investment in equipment, materials, and maintenance.

Material and methods: A literature survey concerning alternative and/or complementary tools for quality control of botanicals has been performed by searching the scientific databases Pubmed, SciFinder, Scopus and Web of Science.

Results: Diverse analytical methods including DNA fingerprinting, Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR), Near Infra Red (NIR) and (bio)sensors have been reported in the literature to evaluate the quality of botanical products. Identification of plants at the species level can be successfully based on genome-based methods, using DNA barcodes, the nucleotide sequence of a short DNA fragment. NMR can provide direct NMR fingerprint determination (complete assignment of the signals by 1D and 2D experiments), quantitative NMR and chemometric analysis (the metabolite fingerprint is based on the distribution of intensity in the NMR spectrum to provide sample classification). NIR spectroscopy is a fast qualitative and quantitative analytical method, getting knowledge about plant species and/or its geographic origin. Finally, the development of chemical and biological sensors is currently one of the most active areas of analytical research. Immobilization of specific enzymes led to recognize definite class of compounds such as cysteine sulfoxides, glucosinolates, cyanogenic glycosides, and polyphenols. Other recognition elements are nucleic acids to evaluate the ability of different molecules to bind DNA. Sensors have also been developed for the detection of heavy metals in botanicals. Moreover, the analysis of mycotoxins and pesticides, could represent another field of possible application.

Conclusions: These alternative/complementary analytical methods represent tools which appear to be an analyst's dream: they are able to give rapid analysis responses; to operate directly on complex matrices, in many cases; to be selective and sensitive enough for the required application; to be portable and sometimes also disposable; and to have fast analysis times.

Keywords: (Bio)sensors; Alternative and/or complementary tools for quality control; DNA profiling; Near Infrared spectroscopy; Nuclear magnetic resonance.