Determining the structural parameters of a molecular layer remains an unresolved problem in surface plasmon resonance (SPR). Given that molecular form and function are intimately coupled, a breakthrough in this area could be of considerable benefit to the study of protein and/or polymer-decorated material interfaces that are ubiquitous in biology and technology. Here, we describe how noninteracting molecules function as innate structural probes that "feel" the intrinsic exclusion volume of a surface-tethered molecular layer in SPR. Importantly, this is noninvasive and provides a means to bypass the refractive index (RI) constraint that convolutes and hinders SPR thickness measurements. To show proof-of-concept, we use BSA molecules in solution to measure the thicknesses of polyethylene glycol (PEG) molecular brushes as a function of molecular weight. The SPR-acquired brush thicknesses scale with PEG hydrodynamic diameter and are in good agreement with atomic force microscopy force-distance measurements. Theoretical treatments that account for changes in the evanescent field decay length at the metal-dielectric interface indicate that the method is most appropriate for low RI layers with an estimated maximal error of ±15% in the thickness due to the RI constraint. Such in situ thickness measurements can be easily incorporated into routine SPR binding assays for investigating mesoscopic structure-function correlations of diverse molecular layers (i.e., biointerfaces).