Activation of a cardiac myocyte P2X4 receptor protects against heart failure. 5'-Phosphonate and 5'-phosphate analogues of AMP containing a (N)-methanocarba (bicyclo[3.1.0]hexane) system could protect from heart failure by potentially activating this cardioprotective channel. Phosphoesters and phosphonodiesters were synthesized and administered in vivo via a miniosmotic pump in a mouse ischemic heart failure model and most significantly increased intact heart contractile function (echocardiography) compared to vehicle infusion. Several new thio and deuterated phosphate derivatives were protective in a calsequestrin (CSQ) overexpressing heart failure model. Diethyl (7, MRS4084) and diisopropyl (8, MRS4074) phosphotriesters were highly protective in the ischemic model. Substitution of 2-Cl with iodo reduced protection in the CSQ model. Diisopropyl ester 16 (MRS2978) of (1'S,2'R,3'S,4'R,5'S)-4'-(6-amino-2-chloropurin-9-yl)-2',3'-(dihydroxy)-1'-(phosphonoethylene)bicyclo[3.1.0]hexane was highly efficacious (CSQ), while lower homologue 1'-phosphonomethylene derivative 14 was inactive. Thus, we identified uncharged carbocyclic nucleotide analogues that represent potential candidates for the treatment of heart failure, suggesting this as a viable and structurally broad approach.