Simple electron self-exchange reactions are often used to study the role of the reaction medium on a chemical process, commonly implying the use of various solvents with different physical properties. In principle, similar studies may be conducted using a single solvent, changing its physical properties by application of elevated pressures, but so far only little information is available on pressure dependent exchange reactions. In this work, we have used a recently constructed high pressure apparatus for use with electron spin resonance (ESR) spectroscopy to investigate simple electron self-exchange reactions involving 2,3-dichloro-5,6-dicyanobenzoquinone (DDQ) and tetracyanoethylene (TCNE) and their respective radical anions as well as TMPPD and its radical cation in three different solvents. The self-exchange was observed by ESR line broadening experiments, yielding rate constants and volumes of activation. The experimental results were compared to theoretical calculations based on Marcus theory and taking into account solvent dynamic effects. The use of elevated pressures has enabled the study of solvent effects without commonly encountered problems like solubility issues or chemical reactions between solvent and solute which sometimes limit the range of useable solvents.