The rearrangement of alpha- and beta-pinene was studied under microwave irradiation in near-critical water and supercritical lower aliphatic alcohols, with the aim of identifying the pathway of alpha- and beta-pinene isomerization. Generally, two pathways occur, pyrolysis on the one and acidolysis on the other hand, whereby acidolysis is predominant in the case of near-critical water and the second pathway is favored for experiments employing supercritical alcohols. The different behavior of these two structurally related solvents is attributed to the increased availability of protons if water is heated to 270 degrees C and 80 bar, thus enhancing the autoprotolysis of water. The application of alcohols instead furnished rearrangement products clearly attributed to thermal pyrolysis route by the formation of radical reaction intermediates.