Establishing a laboratory diagnosis of a bleeding disorder can be challenging for some patients who present with mucocutaneous bleeding symptoms. A common clinical scenario is an older patient with a prior diagnosis of von Willebrand disease (VWD) or a family history of VWD, who now has von Willebrand factor (VWF) values repeatedly within the normal range. Plasma VWF antigen levels have been shown to increase with age. Whether platelet VWF increases with age is unknown. We hypothesized that platelet VWF does not increase with age and low platelet VWF levels, despite normal plasma levels, could be a reason for continued bleeding symptoms in some patients. Therefore, we compared the platelet and plasma VWF antigen and activity as well as the platelet function analyzer (PFA)-100 closure times in 35 patients with a history of mucocutaneous bleeding symptoms and consistently normal levels of VWF antigen and activity, despite a prior history of a VWD diagnosis and/or a positive family history of VWD. Overall in our patients (bleeders), the platelet VWF values correlated with the plasma values and only three patients had reduced platelet VWF. In the bleeding group, the PFA-100 results showed an inverse correlation with plasma and platelet values, which was stronger for the plasma values. Therefore, platelet VWF determination was not helpful in the diagnosis of suspected mild type 1 VWD.